Schmucks R Us: University Presidents Gone Wild!

Well, it’s May, and those of us chained to the delightfully anachronistic agricultural calendar of academe are slathering on the sunscreen, filling up the industrial-sized insulated mug of iced tea, and sitting out in the garden to finish grading exams and calculating final grades.  Inside Higher Ed today provided a good roundup of recent controversies that have been covered here at (or should have been!)  So while most of you are mired in the details of the work that universities are supposed to do, here are some stories about a few university presidents and administrators (you know, the people who have the power to fire you) who are doing a heckuva job.  To wit:

  • West Virginia University President Mike Garrison, a politically-connected appointee without academic credentials or experience, continues to be a universally recognized embarrassment.  (It’s under Garrison’s watch that the business school awarded an M.B.A. to the governor’s daughter despite her not having actually, you know, earned it.  The Dean of the business school and the University Provost resigned recently, but not Garrison, despite his insistence that he “accepts responsibility” for the fraudulent degree.)  The most recent related dust-up reported in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette is that two professors are filing a grievance “after being told their offices are being relocated, a decision they were informed of the day after one of them called for President Mike Garrison’s resignation.”  Anyone who’s worked in an academic department knows that some faculty are very particular about what kind of office they have, its proximity to the department office or bathrooms, how much or how little sunlight, noise level, views, etc.–like Goldilocks, they must have an office that’s “just right.”  This strikes me as the kind of petty, thuggish retaliation that’s characteristic of a political hack, but one who is clearly very attuned to the bizarre obsessions and status games of particular academics.  Well played, Mr. Garrison!  (How long will this guy be permitted to circle the drain at WVU?)
  • Next, in a move that makes Mike Garrison look like Kingman Brewster, Jr., Baylor University’s President John Lilley has apparently reversed 7 out of 12 of his tenure denial decisions on appeal.  (Historiann has reported and commented on the Baylor outrage here, here, and here.)  The Waco Tribune reports that “[t]wo of the cases were reversed after candidates bolstered their publication records, Lilley said, and external letters about the quality of some of the candidates’ research was influential.”  Yeah, right–anyone who knows anything about tenure files knows that it’s utterly impossible to produce something in two months’ time that would reverse a tenure denial, aside from embarassing publicity, poor fundraising, and the wrath of the Board of Regents.  Good news for those faculty members who are now among the elect, but this may make the gendered nature of the tenure denials at Baylor even clearer:  “Names of candidates awarded tenure were not revealed in Lilley’s e-mail, but the Tribune-Herald was able to confirm that three of the seven were engineering faculty Russ Duren, Randall Jean and Carolyn Skurla,” two men and one woman.  (Andrea, if you’re still out there, let us know what you know!) 
  • Finally, Phyllis Schlafly was awarded an honorary degree at Washington University.  Historiann was just flabbergasted by the news that any university (other than Bob Jones or Oral Roberts) would honor Schlafly in this fashion.  What’s next?  Spellman College honors Clarence Thomas?  Calvin College invites Christopher Hitchens to deliver next year’s commencement address?  Memo to Washington University:  next year, try to find a non-self-hating woman, m’kay?  It’s not about “freedom of speech,” it’s about choosing to honor someone whose life’s work is in accordance with the professed values of your institution.  What constituency at Washington U. (or anywhere in the nation) was demanding that Schlafly’s dubious achievements should be honored?  When you choose to honor someone like that, it make you look confused and un-self-confident too.

Here’s an entirely serious end-of-the-academic year question:  Why can’t they just emulate our students and get drunk and act like a$$holes?  It’s easy, it’s fun, and as long as you don’t drive, there’s little chance that it will make the morning papers.


0 thoughts on “Schmucks R Us: University Presidents Gone Wild!

  1. Thanks, Prof. Z! I was having a hard time getting some of my Vargas-like cowgirl images to fit, and then thought that maybe the big splinter in the skirt was a good metaphor for whatever the hell is going on at WVU, Baylor, and Wash. U. (I’m trying to avoid splinters myself these days!)

    And GayProf: too true. Although I think the invitations have been much less forthcoming in his second term than they were in his first. Mr. 26% Approval Rating probably wouldn’t be such a coup, now, would it?


  2. Bing–I’ve heard about that article, but I just can’t read that right now. I can post on Barbie Death Camp, but I can’t deal with Schlafly’s level of hostility and stupidity. But, I suppose that’s what’s great about positioning yourself against the Enlightenment and education and rational inquiry: there’s always something to be hatin’ on coming out of universities these days.

    I had hoped you would do a post on Schlafly, since her presence defiled your graduation! (Or were you Too Cool for School to be hooded in public?)


  3. A student said to me last week: “My father warned me not to go to college because it was full of liberals. I was somewhat concerned about this before I got here, but I have found that in fact you do not have to be liberal to be rational.”


  4. Actually, I ended up on the local news, apparently. I did not see it, but my sister said that there was a close shot of me waving to my parents and that they lingered on me for a number of seconds. I went to the website of the station to see the report, but durn it, they did not have any video clips posted. Oh well. I know what I look like, and lord only knows how many pictures the family took.

    Those hoods are surprisingly heavy. I also got the tam and gold tassle. I look so medieval/gospel choir.



  5. Now you’re outfitted for every commencement ceremony you’ll attend as faculty for the rest of your career. (Believe me, the charm wears off, but at least you can wear just a t-shirt and shorts underneath those dignified robes.


Leave a Reply to Historiann Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.